While listening in on a debate between my teenage son and a group of his friends from the neighborhood the other day, I was very amused to find that not only do they believe it to be a toss up between Kobe Bryant and Lebron James as to who the best player in the NBA is but they even went as far as to say that these two are the greatest basketball players in NBA history.
Upon hearing this proclamation, my first reaction was to immediately chuckle to myself. “They have got to be kidding me”, I mused quietly seconds before I exploded into a roar of laughter. “Magic Johnson is the greatest basketball player of all time! Are you kidding me”? I chimed in as I ridiculed these “uninformed” teens. “You all are just saying that Kobe and Lebron are the best because that is all that you have seen in the short time that you have been on Earth”.
Being one that has always been blessed with the proverbial “gift of gab”, it is a rare occasion when I am speechless but on this particular occasion I was literally muted when these kids responded to my accusation of generational prejudice: “Well pops, could it be that you are saying that Magic Johnson is the best basketball player of all time because he is from YOUR era”?
To be completely honest, they had a very good point. Maybe I was being just a little bit prejudice by favoring a player from my era and perhaps it is simply human nature to do so. In the words of the great Isaac Hayes: I stand accused. Guilty as charged!
As a consequence of my indictment, I decided to examine this issue in greater detail and attempt to find the elusive answer to the question of who is the greatest NBA player of all time without interjecting any personal feelings. But how? Hmmm? I wonder.
Ultimately, I concluded that the only way to remove any personal feelings from my quest to solve this enigma was to look at the numbers and see exactly what some of the greats have accomplished in their careers. My short list of candidates was admittedly chosen subjectively but I believe fairly and I am confident that most critics would feel comfortable with it.
Being that this entire inquiry was initiated from a Lebron/Kobe debate I had to include both of these young superstars in my short list of candidates. The remaining candidates include: Michael Jordan, Magic Johnson, Larry Bird, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Wilt Chamberlain and Bill Russell. Let’s us take a look and see what the facts actually are and crunch the numbers to get a better perspective as to exactly what kind of careers these hardwood giants had.
My initial thoughts were to look at career longevity first and foremost reasoning that if one is trying to ascertain who the greatest NBA athlete of all time is; the player’s entire body of work must be evaluated. If in fact the player’s entire body of work is incomplete than there is nothing to evaluate and this person must be immediately eliminated. In light of this, I concluded that Lebron James must be eliminated from this debate because although he has been impressive in his short career, he has only been in the league 7 years which is an insufficient amount of time to make any claims of all time greatness for him. Perhaps we can revisit this debate in another 7 years or so but for now Lebron must go to the bench.
Kobe Bryant; however, makes a great case for being the greatest of all time. He has been in the league a total of 14 years after being drafted by the Charlotte Hornets as the 13th pick of the 1996 NBA draft upon choosing to immediately enter the NBA after graduating from high school. He was subsequently traded to the Los Angeles Lakers for Vlade Divac in what may turn out to be one of the worst trades in the history of professional sports.
Since joining the league in 1996, Kobe has averaged and impressive 25.3 points, 5.3 rebounds, 4.7 assists, 1.5 steals and 2.9 turnovers per game. Kobe scored a career high 81 points against Toronto on 1/22/06, has won 4 NBA championships with the Lakers and has been selected to the NBA all star team 11 times. The greatest testament of all in terms of Kobe’s greatness however may very well be the fact that he was able to win an NBA championship without the assistance of future hall of famer Shaquille Oneal with whom he won three consecutive championships in 2001, 2002 and 2003.
For years it had been whispered in certain circles that Kobe would never win a championship without the big man in the middle but those whispers were forever put to rest once and for all in 2009 when Kobe Bryant led the Los Angeles Lakers to their 15 NBA championship. Kobe certainly is a viable candidate for the title of greatest NBA player of all time but is he even the greatest Laker of all time? Let’s see.
They called him “Magic” and he was my sentimental choice for greatest NBA player of all time. This 6’9” point guard with the big smile from Michigan State University was so good that they changed the name of the game from basketball to “Showtime” in Los Angeles during his tenure there. Earvin “Magic” Johnson was so good that he along with Larry Bird was able to transition the NBA from the floundering league which it had been during the era of Dr. “J” to the highly successful league which it had become by the time in which the baton was passed to Michael Jordan in the late 1980’s.
The ultimate floor general, “Magic” was able to elevate the game of everyone that he played with and his incredible no-look passes and up-tempo fast break style was so revolutionary that it was even able to convert a journeyman player from Greece named Kirk Rambis into a fan favorite and 4 time NBA champion.
In his first 12 seasons before revealing the he had tragically contracted HIV and was forced to retire early, Magic averaged 19.5 points, 11.2 assists, 7.2 rebounds, 1.9 steals and 3.9 turnovers per game. A 12 time NBA all star, Magic was able to lead the Lakers to 5 NBA championships including back to back championships in 1987 and 1988. He was named as one of the 50 greatest NBA players in 1996, was a 9 time NBA 1st team selection, and was inducted into the Naismith Memorial Basket Hall of Fame in 2002. In my opinion he is the greatest Laker of all time and quite possibly the greatest player ever but I said that I was going to be non-partial so let’s continue on our quest for the greatest ever.
Larry Joe Bird played his entire 13 year career with the Boston Celtics and his name will forever be linked to his nemesis and friend Magic Johnson. During the NBA’s transitional years of the 80’s, the fierce rivalry between the Lakers and the Celtics was once again rekindled and the rivalry between Bird and Magic which had it’s beginning in the 1979 NCAA basketball finals continued on for many years.
Nicknamed “Larry the Legend”, Bird was a 9 time NBA all star, 3 time NBA champion, 9 time NBA 1st team selection, 2 time NBA finals MVP, 50 greatest NBA player selection and Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame inductee in 1998.
In 13 NBA seasons, Larry “The Hick from French Lick” Bird averaged 24.3 points, 10 rebounds, 6.3 assists and 1.7 steals per game. Being a long time Atlanta Hawks fan, Larry Bird has stuck a dagger in my heart many times as he would annually and single handedly put my beloved Hawks out of the playoffs.
He was just damn hard to beat and there was nothing anyone could do about it. I literally hated him (in a sports hatred kind of way) and I hated the Celtic team just as vehemently. The guy could play the game and as much as I hate to admit it, he is a legitimate candidate for the greatest NBA player of all time title. But is he? Let us continue our quest for the greatest of all time.
As the baton was passed from the Bird-Magic era to the next generation, a young man from North Carolina would change the game for ever on and off the court. With the quickness of a deer and the leaping ability of a cheetah, Michael Jordan showed the world how to play above the rim as it had never been done before. As he would gracefully float through the air and glide to the hoop while others succumbed to the inevitable effects of gravity, he would slam the ball home with authority with his tongue hanging out of his mouth as if he were sticking it out at his opponent in defiance. Michael Jordan’s uncanny ability to hang in the air for what seemed an eternity earned him the nickname “Air Jordan” and deservedly so.
Entering the league in 1984, Air Jordan went on to play a total of 15 stellar seasons in the NBA. He was named league MVP 5 times, won 6 championships (2 three-peats), received 14 all star nominations, 10 1st team NBA honors, was named rookie of the year and was acknowledged as one of the 50 greatest players in NBA history. He averaged 30.1 points, 5.3 assists, 6.2 rebounds, and an amazing 2.35 steals per game in his illustrious career. He was enshrined in to the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame in 2009.
Not only did Jordan excel on the court but his commercial appeal was unmatched by any athlete before him and since with possibly the exception of Tiger Woods. Due to the enormity of his popularity, he earned millions and millions of dollars in endorsements and paved the way for the modern athlete to enhance their fortunes beyond the playing field. Michael “Air” Jordan is quite possibly the greatest NBA player ever but let’s continue what we have started in pursuit of the greatest of all time.
Born Lew Alcindor on 8/16/1947, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, entered the NBA in 1969 after being drafted by the Milwaukee Bucks. He would win the first of 6 NBA championships in 1971 and would go on to play a record 20 seasons in the NBA. He is the all time leader in points scored, games played and was at the time of his retirement the all time leader in blocks.
Kareem was an integral part of “Showtime” along with Magic Johnson and James Worthy and his patented sky-hook shot is still considered the most lethal offensive weapon the NBA has ever seen. He average 24.6 points, 11.2 blocks, 3.6 steals and 2.7
blocks per game in his phenomenal career and certainly should be considered in any debate pertaining to the greatest NBA player that ever lived. Perhaps he is?
If there ever was a mountain of a man and a physical specimen the likes of which had never been seen before, it was Wilton Norman Chamberlain. At 7’1” tall and weighing 275 pounds Wilt Chamberlain was simply unstoppable. Drafted by the Philadelphia Warriors in the 1959 NBA draft, Wilt Chamberlain went on to play 16 seasons in the NBA. His statistics are mind boggling to say the least. Check this out!
During his career Wilt “The Stilt” Chamberlain averaged 30.1 points, 22.9 rebounds and 4.4 assists per game. He scored a ridiculous 100 points in a single game, 4000 points in one season, snatched 55 rebounds in a game, average 50.4 points per game one season (1961) and even led the league in assists in 1967. Imagine that!
Wilt Chamberlain was a 2 time NBA champion, 4 times NBA MVP, 7 times 1st team NBA, Naismith Memorial Hall of Fame Inductee (1978) and a member of the NBA 50 greatest players. His 23,924 rebounds are still an NBA record and at the time of his retirement he was the NBA’s all time leading scorer. There cannot be any discussion concerning the greatest player in NBA history that does not include Wilton Norman Chamberlain. Period!
The Celtics have had many great players in their storied history as I am sure anyone that knows the slightest little bit about professional basketball can attest but the most famous Celtic of all is next to be scrutinized along our quest to determine the greatest NBA player of all time.
Bill Russell was the cornerstone of the Boston Celtics during their dynastic days of the
1960’s. In 13 seasons in the NBA Bill Russell won an incredible 11 championships! Yes that is right! I said 11 championships in 13 seasons! This is a feat that in my opinion will never be duplicated. He was a 5 time NBA MVP, 12 times an all star and even won a championship as a player/coach. He had a ridiculous streak of 12 consecutive seasons of 1000 rebounds or more and snatched an unbelievable 51 rebounds in a single game.
During his career Bill Russell averaged 15.1 points, 22.5 rebounds and 4.3 assists per game and is considered to be quite possibly the greatest defensive player of all time. He titanic battles against Wilt Chamberlain are legendary and they were fierce competitors on the court but great friends on the court. Russell was the only person of their era that could slightly neutralize Wilt Chamberlain although nobody ever completely stopped him. Bill Russell was a man among men and cannot be omitted from any conversation concerning the greatest NBA player of all time either.
Well there you have it. That pretty much sums up the accomplishments of my list of finalists for the title of the greatest player in NBA history. All of these incredible basketball players have accomplishments that are stratospheric and it is extremely difficult to make a decision as to who is the best among them based upon statistics because each one of these behemoths excelled in different areas. For example what is more impressive: Wilt Chamberlains 100 point game, Kareem’s 19 all star appearances, Michael Jordan’s 2 3-peats or Bill Russell’s 12 seasons of at least 1000 rebounds?
With much careful thought, I have to give the nod to Bill Russell and his 11 NBA championships. Many times I have seen great players with exemplary statistics denied there due simply because they did not have an NBA championship as the crown to their careers. The great Dominique Wilkins comes immediately to mind who upon retirement was number 7 all time in NBA scoring history but was inexplicably omitted from the 50 greatest NBA player’s team of 1996 simply because he never won a championship.
Bill Russell’s 11 championships in 13 seasons simply is an amazing accomplishment. To put it in perspective, Bill Russell has as many NBA Championship rings as Kobe Bryant, Lebron James, Magic Johnson and Larry Bird combined. Grasp this if you will. He averaged an incredible 22.5 rebounds per game for his career! I remember when the great Dennis Rodman was receiving tremendous accolades for leading the NBA in rebounding with an average of 15 boards per game during the 1997/1998 season. That feat was quite impressive but is dwarfed in comparison to what Bill Russell was able to accomplish. He averaged 22.5 rebounds for his CAREER! Need I say more?
Well I guess that all of this conjecture is still merely my opinion regardless of the numbers that I have presented but my mind is certainly made up. I repeat that Bill Russell is the greatest player in NBA history. Perhaps you have a different view. If so feel free to leave a comment. I am certainly interested in hearing it.
















They don’t want your accolades. They don’t want your praise or adulation. They certainly don’t want any more of my journalistic banter. They merely want to be left alone as they strive to come towards the conclusion of a long and arduous journey which had transformed a once proud and exemplary organization from the elite upper echelons of the NFL to the bitter thralls of the completely inept.




